OSTLAND by David Thomas


(Affixed to this barbed wire fence surrounding the Minsk ghetto is a sign stating “Warning: anyone climbing the fence will be shot!”)

In 1963 Hannah Arendt published her landmark work EICHMANN IN JERUSALEM: ON THE BANALITY OF EVIL which provoked a fierce debate concerning the 1961 trial of Nazi bureaucrat Adolf Eichmann. The book examines moral responsibility, bureaucracy, justice, and how ordinary people participate in atrocities as she goes on to argue that Eichmann was driven less by sadistic or demonic hatred than by careerism, obedience, and an inability to think critically or take another person’s perspective.  Rather than being a monstrous mastermind, Eichmann appears as a functionary hiding behind clichés, euphemisms, and official language while organizing deportations to death camps.  The debate that Arendt fostered is at the heart of David Thomas’ excellent novel OSTLAND whose main character evolves from a law abiding policeman in the 1930s to a mass murderer implementing the Holocaust.

Thomas’ novel is based on a true story of Georg Hauser, a Berlin detective who was credited with solving the S-Bahn murders and eventually was prosecuted as a war criminal.  Thomas begins the novel  with the investigation into a serial killer who is using S-Bahn train stations as his hunting ground.  Thomas will describe a series of murders and rapes on unsuspecting victims and uses Hauser as his narrator.  Hauser works for Wilhelm Ludke who is the head of the Berlin murder squad and is appointed as lead investigator for hunting down the killer.  Thomas accurately creates the mood of Germany after World War I as many felt that Germany was “stabbed in the back,” experienced the rising tide of antisemitism, and hyperinflation leading to the rise of Adolf Hitler. 


(The placard reads “we are partisans who shot at German soldiers.)

The novel at times reads like non-fiction as historical characters such as Heinrich Himmler, Reinhard Heydrich, Arthur Nebe, Hans Lobbes, and Bernard Wehrer make their appearance.  At the outset Hauser comes across as a Bernie Gunther type – a wise cracking sarcastic character from Philip Kerr’s series on the Criminal Police Force (Kripo).  However, as the novel evolves we realize that Hauser is a much more sinister character.  Thomas describes Hauser and Ludtke as law abiding officers who went about capturing the killer, Paul Ogorzow, a railroad worker, described as a sexual predator consumed by his hatred of women. 

In June 1941, the German Army will launch its invasion of Russia to achieve Lebensraum (living space in the east) hoping to use the Ukraine as a break basket for the German people and a place to settle excess population.  Hauser like many German police officers was transferred to the eastern front to carry out Hitler’s grand plan.  In early autumn 1941, Hauser was promoted to Criminal Police Commissar and SS-First Lieutenant and was sent to Riga as part of Einsatzgruppe-Sonderkommando B under the command of SS-Lieutenant-Colonel Erich Ehrlinger.  Hauser believed he was part of a mission to bring civilization and the rule of law to a distant province still mired in barbarism.

At this point Thomas introduces Max Kraus and Paula Siebert, post war prosecutors who are charged with bringing about the conviction of Hauser and his associates for a series of Nazi “Actions” against the Jews of Minsk.  We follow the development of the case and gathering of evidence and how difficult it was to gain a just conviction.  Legal gymnastics dominate as Siebert in particular becomes concerned they will not reach a conviction.  The dialogue between Kraus and Siebert (who are having an affair throughout) is fascinating as they try to achieve justice for Hauser’s victims. 

(Jews rounded up in the Minsk Ghetto)

The focal point of the novel is the city of Minsk, the Jewish ghetto created within the city, and the environs outside the city which became a killing field of Jews as large pits were dug to bury them.  It is here that Thomas delves deeply into Hauser’s psyche trying to rationalize his murderous behavior.  It is interesting how the author integrates a certain logic into the novel particularly as it pertains to the Nazis.  For example, there is an assumption that party members, SA or SS by definition, as loyal National Socialists were incapable of committing heinous crimes because they were only following the laws of the Nazi state.  If one follows the law, their actions could not be considered criminal.  This is a large part of Hauser’s moral gymnastics as he justifies his behavior overseeing the death of thousands of Jews and shooting hundreds himself.  When Hauser looks in the mirror he has difficulty rationalizing how he went from hunting a serial killer, into becoming a serial killer.

Thomas has completed a great deal of research in preparing his novel and his presentation is historically accurate.  The author offers a precise description of the Minsk ghetto and a details as to how Jews were transported from Vienna to Minsk, their treatment upon arrival, and their ultimate execution.  Thomas goes as far as using SS figures to determine the cost to the German nation for the death of each Jew.  The question of who was coopted into shooting so many Jews and burying them in pits relies on the work of Christopher Browning whose exceptional volume, ORDINARY MEN: RESERVE POLICE BATALLION 101AND THE FINAL SOLUTION IN POLAND explores the role of men who were too old or young to fight on the eastern front or were retired police officers, including those with disability who helped  carry out the mass murder in the east.  Hauser would command these types of individuals as they carried out orders from “higher ups.”  One might ask how anyone could carry out such atrocities, the answer lies in part the use of vodka as a tool to dull their senses so they could stomach their own behavior.


(Masha Bruskina, a Jewish Soviet partisan hanged with two other partisans, Krill Trus and Volodya Sherbateyvich. The sign reads: “We are partisans who shot at German soldiers.”)

Thomas employs Hauser as his narrator in describing the plight of the Jews.  No matter the situation, Hauser’s fall back position is that one cannot question orders.  For Hauser, the people carrying out the extermination of Jews are servants of the state therefore they have no moral responsibility for their actions.  Hauser was able to survive any moral conundrum by distracting himself from the truth – he lived in a constant state of denial as he rationalized; that as long as he was acting for the benefit of the state he was not culpable.  Hauser’s personal journey to reach his state of mind evolved from empathy, guilt, to acceptance in explaining to himself that as a law abiding German citizen it was his duty to carry out orders.

Thomas will effectively alternate chapters throughout the book describing events in Minsk and the courtroom in Coblenz.  Thomas is a master at creating scenes that reconstruct the horrors perpetrated by the Nazis, the courtroom drama, and the thought processes that all the major characters actions.  This is especially important as Siebert will interview Hauser who was an experienced interrogator himself, and to an extent plays with her as much as he plays with the ambiguities he understands all too well from experience.  When society makes crime part of its raison d’etre, who is the criminal?

The creation of the Lang family and their interaction with Hauser encapsulates the dilemmas that victims faced as the Holocaust was carried out.  Hauser demented belief that he was not a bad person as he went about saving the Lang family rationalizing that they were blonde and since only a grandfather was Jewish they could not be considered Jews is inane.  The dilemma of each Lang family member is on full display as people succumb to the barbarity that their lives have become in order to try and survive.

Once Hauser and his accomplices are convicted and sentenced, Thomas engages in a soliloquy in trying to explain the conviction and sentencing which any moral person would find bone chilling.  The book itself is not easy to classify, but it is a thought provoking description of an ordinary person’s capacity to commit evil.  Thomas’ measured descriptions of how the Holocaust was carried out and the moral quandaries that resulted turn a gripping thriller into an important examination of a tragic subject.

(Entrance to the Minsk Ghetto)

Leave a Reply